Against Facts (MIT Press) by Arianna Betti

By Arianna Betti

In this booklet Arianna Betti argues that we have got no solid cause to simply accept proof in our catalog of the area, a minimum of as they're defined via the 2 significant metaphysical theories of proof. She claims that neither of those theories is tenable -- neither the speculation in response to which proof are particular established development blocks of truth nor the idea in line with which proof are no matter what is called via convinced expressions of the shape "the indisputable fact that such and such." there's fact, and there are entities actually that we will identify, yet, Betti contends, between those entities there are not any facts.Drawing on metaphysics, the philosophy of language, and linguistics, Betti examines the most arguments in prefer of and opposed to evidence of the 2 significant varieties, which she distinguishes as compositional and propositional, giving exact cognizance to methodological presuppositions. She criticizes compositional proof (facts as exact established development blocks of fact) and the primary argument for them, Armstrong's truthmaker argument. She then criticizes propositional evidence (facts as no matter what is called in "the incontrovertible fact that" statements) and what she calls the argument from nominal reference, which pulls on Quine's criterion of ontological dedication. Betti argues that metaphysicians may still cease caring approximately proof, and philosophers quite often may still cease arguing for or opposed to entities at the foundation of the way we use language.

Show description

Read or Download Against Facts (MIT Press) PDF

Similar metaphysics books

Immanuel Kant: Prolegomena to Any Future Metaphysics: That Will Be Able to Come Forward as Science: With Selections from the Critique of Pure Reason (Cambridge Texts in the History of Philosophy)

Kant is the relevant determine of recent philosophy. He sought to rebuild philosophy from the floor up, and he succeeded in completely altering its difficulties and strategies. This new, revised variation of the Prolegomena, that is the simplest advent to the theoretical aspect of his philosophy, provides his suggestion in actual fact by means of paying cautious realization to his unique language.

The Nature of Philosophical Problems: Their Causes and Implications

We needs to all make offerings approximately how we wish to reside. We overview our percentages through counting on historic, ethical, own, political, spiritual, and medical modes of reviews, however the values and purposes that stick with from them clash. Philosophical difficulties are compelled on us once we try and do something about such conflicts.

Aerobics for the Mind: Practical Exercises in Philosophy that Anybody Can Do

Keep in mind if you happen to have been a toddler and continuously requested your mom and dad “Why? ” you continue to had that adolescence present of thinking about approximately every little thing from the easy “Why can’t I contact the range eye whilst it’s pink? ” to the main profound questions humans can ask “Why can’t I see God if He’s genuine? ”A universal notion of philosophers is of the wizened previous guru, sitting on a mountain best considering his navel; or worse, a stodgy, uninteresting highbrow that everybody avoids at events.

God, Truth, and other Enigmas (Philosophische Analyse / Philosophical Analysis)

The ebook God, fact, and different Enigmas is a suite of eighteen essays that fall lower than 4 headings: (God's) Existence/Non-Existence, Omniscience, fact, and Metaphysical Enigmas. The essays differ broadly in subject and tone. they supply the reader with an summary of up to date philosophical techniques to the topics which are indicated within the identify of the ebook.

Extra resources for Against Facts (MIT Press)

Sample text

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.23 of 5 – based on 7 votes